12 Apr 2023

The Art Of Rejecting: 8 Ways To Provide Constructive Feedback To Unsuccessful Candidates

unsuccessful candidates feedback | Exacta Solutions

Discover the best tips to providing constructive interview feedback to unsuccessful candidates.

Offering feedback to unsuccessful job candidates is an essential aspect of the hiring process, yet many hiring managers find it challenging. It can be difficult to deliver news that someone did not get the job, but it’s crucial to provide constructive feedback that can help unsuccessful candidates improve their future prospects.

In this article, we will share tips on how to give impactful and helpful feedback to unsuccessful candidates, so they can use the experience to grow and succeed in their next job search. But first …

Why is it important to provide constructive feedback to unsuccessful candidates?

Providing constructive feedback to unsuccessful candidates is crucial in the hiring process. Not only does it help the candidate understand the reasons why they were not selected for the position, but it also gives them an opportunity to enhance their skills for future job opportunities. Additionally, offering feedback demonstrates that you value the time and effort the candidate invested in the application process, and that you are willing to provide guidance and support. This positive experience helps to create a good impression of your company in the job market, attracting more qualified candidates to your organisation.

Moreover, keeping a positive relationship with unsuccessful candidates encourages them to apply for other roles in your company, potentially saving you time and resources on recruitment and training. So, let’s prioritise providing constructive feedback to unsuccessful candidates, as it can be an essential factor in building a positive employer brand and fostering a supportive workplace culture.

8 Tips for Giving Feedback to Unsuccessful Interviewees

Providing feedback to unsuccessful candidates can be a tricky task for recruiters and hiring managers. However, there are some important principles to keep in mind that can help ensure the feedback is valuable and well-received. With these principles in mind, we’ve compiled eight tips for giving effective feedback to candidates:

constructive interview feedback | Exacta Solutions1 – Provide feedback in a timely manner

Giving feedback in a timely manner is a crucial aspect of providing a positive interview experience for unsuccessful candidates. It’s important to remember that candidates may have invested a lot of time and effort into the interview process and may be eagerly waiting for feedback. Delaying the process can leave them feeling uncertain and without closure. Not only is timely feedback a professional courtesy, but it can also help mitigate any negative word-of-mouth about your company. Candidates who feel that they have been treated respectfully and given timely feedback are more likely to have a positive perception of your company, even if they weren’t successful in this particular role.

2 – Thank the candidate for their interest and effort

Candidates invest a lot of time and energy in the interview process, which can make it disheartening if they feel like their efforts were wasted and unappreciated. To avoid this, it’s crucial to show appreciation for their interest and effort, even if they weren’t selected for the role. Thanking the candidate for their time and interest at the beginning of the feedback conversation is not only respectful but also a great way to acknowledge their effort. This sets a positive tone and builds a good rapport with the candidate, making them feel valued and appreciated, making it more likely they’ll take your notes on board.

3 – Personalise the feedback

It’s also important to avoid generic responses that offer little value. Simply stating that they were unsuccessful will not cut it. Instead, aim to personalise the feedback to each candidate as much as possible. This can be achieved by reviewing your interview notes and highlighting specific areas where the candidate excelled or areas where they struggled. Providing specific praise for what you liked about their interviewing style can help to boost their confidence and encourage them to continue refining their skills. Similarly, highlighting any specific issues that may have contributed to them not landing the job can provide valuable insights which they can use to improve their performance in future interviews.

4 – Be honest yet tactful

Providing honest feedback to candidates is key to helping them grow, but it’s important to balance honesty with tact. Avoid making any personal remarks that could be taken as offensive. Instead, focus on constructive solutions and avoid negative phrases, highlighting the candidate’s strengths and offering suggestions for improvement. However, it’s also important to be prepared for candidates who may not take the feedback well. Should this happen it’s crucial to remain professional throughout any email exchanges or conversations.

giving interview feedback to candidates | Exacta Solutions5 – Provide actionable tips

Offering constructive feedback to unsuccessful candidates is a crucial step in enhancing their interview experience and helping them grow in their career. One way to do this is to clearly explain to them why they didn’t make the cut for the role they applied for. For example, if a candidate lacks experience in a certain skill or field, be honest and provide actionable steps they can take to improve.

By providing specific and actionable feedback, candidates can better understand what they need to work on and can apply this knowledge to future interviews. This helps create a positive candidate experience and strengthens your company’s reputation as a supportive and thoughtful employer.

6 – Provide helpful resources

Pointing candidates towards helpful resources is an often overlooked aspect of providing feedback. While it’s essential to offer constructive criticism and explain why the candidate was not selected, it’s equally important to point them in the right direction to help them improve their skills and succeed in future interviews. By recommending relevant resources such as courses, internships, or volunteering opportunities, candidates can work on developing the skills necessary to excel in their chosen field. Additionally, providing tips on how to approach the interview process can also prove to be highly beneficial.

7 – Make time to follow up to their questions

It’s important to remember that candidates may have follow-up questions or want to clarify specific points you made in your feedback. Taking the time to answer these questions can be incredibly valuable to the candidates. By being open to follow-up conversations, you show that you value the candidate’s time and effort and are willing to invest in their development. Moreover, it can create a good impression of your company and keep the door open for potential future opportunities.

8 – Encourage candidates to apply for future roles

In addition to providing feedback and resources to unsuccessful candidates, it’s important to leave the door open for future opportunities. Even if a candidate wasn’t the perfect fit for a current role, they may be an ideal candidate for a future position. Encourage them to keep in touch by connecting on professional platforms like LinkedIn and letting them know that you appreciate their interest in the company. By maintaining a positive relationship, you may be able to tap into their skills and experience when a relevant position becomes available. In short, don’t discount the value of a candidate just because they didn’t make the cut this time around – keep the lines of communication open for potential opportunities in the future.

Elevate your workplace IQ with our insightful guides. Don’t miss out on the latest updates – subscribe to the Exacta Solutions newsletter now.